Employee fraud: an overlooked risk for UK SMEs


UK SMEs are losing £18 billion every year to fraud, says a recent study, with 35% falling victim in the past year. How can the fraud threat be stopped?

The most obvious cost of fraud is immediate: research from Sage Pay found that UK small to medium sized businesses lose an average of £3,450.

But the financial loss can pale into insignificance when compared with the reputational damage. Bad publicity associated with a fraud can negatively influence suppliers, customers and potential employees, discourage investors and affect relations with regulators.

Despite these serious consequences, too many SMEs are unwittingly exposing themselves to the risk of fraud. Almost a third of SMEs (32%) do not spend money on fraud prevention and the average investment in fraud prevention, £1,881 annually, is just half the average cost of fraud.

Perhaps most striking is the failure to use simple existing systems to tackle fraud. Many don’t even use some of the tools and checks that come as standard with payment gateways, with only 22% using CV2.

But the most common cause of fraud can come as a surprise to many small to medium sized businesses.

Insider fraud threat

Contrary to popular belief, most workplace crime is carried out by employees. Common types of ‘insider fraud’ include: asset theft, payroll fraud, corruption, theft of intellectual property and selling sensitive company information.

Companies that are underperforming or failing to motivate staff are more likely to suffer fraud. However, there is usually a personal factor such as uncertainty about employment, money worries such as debt, illness or gambling problems. Indeed, one well-worn phrase has it that “fast women and slow horses” lead employees to commit fraud. Secrecy and stress should be investigated, not just for fear of fraud, but also to ensure employee welfare.

Jokes aside, behaviour that is not exactly suspicious but still unusual, such as refusing to take a holiday, can be a sign that something is wrong. This reticence to take a break is a red flag to official fraud investigators as it may mean the employee is concerned that their crimes may be uncovered.

Close relationships with suppliers are usually to be lauded. But being too cosy could suggest corrupt activities such as inflated invoices and kickbacks to the employee.

How can owners and managers get to grips with such subtleties and protect their business. As a minimum, SME owners need to have a stated anti-fraud policy that:

  • Verifies anti-fraud work practices are followed and detects fraudulent activity
  • Develops written procedures that map out work processes in areas vulnerable to fraud
  • Checks everything is happening as it should, including balancing and dividing key responsibilities

A few simple tips can help build this plan and cut the risk of employee fraud:

Top tips for tackling insider fraud

  1. Use an auditor – the expense may seem unnecessary but can often be paid for by preventing a single case of fraud. Auditors have an independent view of your controls and can check company finances.
  2. Spread responsibilities – having a single person in control of an important area leaves little room for safety checks. ‘Segregation of duties’ (or ‘dual control procedures’) means ensuring that no one person controls a transaction form beginning to end. More people involved means fraud is harder to commit and easier to spot.
  3. Tighten log-ins – have software that requires users to change their password at regular intervals; this will lock out any fraudsters that have copied someone else’s details and discourage those who are caught from passing the blame.
  4. Check out new employees – be extremely vigilant in checking references and contacting previous employers. There are specific databases for employers that provide information regarding potential employees.

Related Articles

Powerlines-into-sunrise

Energy News – 27/06/2017

A deal with the DUP may be yet to materialise, but that hasn’t stopped the Queen’s speech going ahead, wit...

Read More

Switching just got simpler for micro businesses

45% of micro businesses are stuck on expensive deals New regulations from the CMA will make it easier for thes...

Read More
Business-electricity-coal-power-to-end-by-2023-big-coal-stockpile-at-sunrise

Energy News 16/06/2017

Michael Gove is appointed energy secretary, suppliers continue to fall short on digital offerings and global e...

Read More
Excellent, 9.7 / 10

Extremely helpful and clear to understand

"I have found the information and assistance to be very clear, and helpful. I was helped through the process of switching electricity supply by personal switching assistant Suhan Ashan who was not only helpful, but very patient in explaining all of the queries which I had and also researching the estimated KwH for our newly acquired office premises, as we had no previous tenant information."

This review was posted by Sue Williams on the 24th of July 2017

Jessica help us arrange new deals for …

"Jessica help us arrange new deals for our start up business which was greatly useful particularly in time during busy setting out period"

This review was posted by Allan on the 21st of July 2017

Really good doing business with Mark …

"Really good doing business with Mark Weeks and SwitchMyBusiness. Getting good energy deals for not-for-profit organisations are a nightmare but Mark made it really easy for us. Very many thanks, well done!"

This review was posted by Tony Smith on the 20th of July 2017

Spoke with Mark Weeks great guy always …

"Spoke with Mark Weeks great guy always phoned back or email when he said he would and was a great help. Would use him again any time."

This review was posted by Duncan Winton on the 20th of July 2017

Courteous and knowledgeable.

"I had my business transfer handled by Mark Weeks, he was courteous and knowledgeable about the various different tariffs on offer and made the process quick and simple. I would definitely recommend their services."

This review was posted by Lawrie Sharp on the 19th of July 2017