quote
menu

Litigation against SME directors: a growing issue


Personal claims against company decision-makers are on the rise. Who is vulnerable, under what circumstances and how can you reduce the risks?

Did you know that a claim can be brought not just against a business, but its individual directors, owners or managers? What’s more, these kinds of cases, known as D&O (Directors and Officers), which took off in the US in the late 1980s, are becoming increasingly common across Western Europe.

Who is vulnerable to a D&O claim?

Anyone who makes major decisions in your company is vulnerable to a D&O prosecution case. Typically within an SME, this will be an owner, partner or director. In any case, it will be a person with the power to make major business decisions. As Allianz says of such personnel:

‘No matter how prudently they act and how strong their business acumen is, any manager’s decision can result in losses for the company or a third party, and the directors and officers who made those decisions can be held personally liable for those losses and can be involved in costly litigation.’

D&O claims can be made by a variety of third-parties, including:

  • Employees, past and present
  • Investors
  • Clients
  • Shareholders
  • Suppliers
  • Tax authorities
  • Social security
  • Competitors

D&O cases can even be made (and lost) by directors themselves.

Trethowans Solicitors recently obtained a costs order against the principal director of a company who had brought a speculative claim. The director brought the case to court through defending the safety of his product (the litigation concerned the fitness for purpose of a product that had been adapted for use in the oilfield industry but which had been rejected on the grounds of safety).

He alleged that those who had come up with an alternative product to alleviate those safety concerns had been motivated by spurious reasons and acted in bad faith. If the claim had been successful, the director would have stood to benefit financially. Therefore, when the case was unsuccessful, the courts ruled him personally liable for the loss.

Why are D&O claims made against individuals?

D&O claims against individual decision-makers can arise from many different contexts. For example:

  • An employee might sue a director for discrimination on the grounds of age or sex
  • A director might be prosecuted by an authority for his or her personal failure to comply with laws or regulations
  • Misrepresentation or inadequate disclosure might cause a client to claim damages
  • A shareholder might prosecute if they felt that a manager or director had made a decision that caused avoidable financial loss

AS Green & Co. Insurance Brokers cite the following real-life D&O claims:

An engineering firm’s directors were sued when they dismissed an employee without following a fair dismissal process. The claim was settled out of court at £50,000.

A director of a management consultancy made derogatory remarks about a client, based on confidential information he had seen about them. The client sued for defamation and the firm’s data protection practices were investigated by the authorities.

A former director of a company prosecuted the other directors, claiming that they had wrongly calculated his pension benefits, leading to a large financial shortfall.

These examples show that D&O claims can be extremely varied in their nature, which makes it hard to know where they might come from.

How can you minimise the risk of a D&O claim?

Companies can minimise their exposure to D&O suits by following good corporate practice and regularly reminding directors and senior managers of their duties. But the reality is that smaller businesses often need to take risks in order to thrive. As Allianz say, company decision-makers “constantly walk a fine line, making tough and complex decisions with huge impacts on the basis of the sometimes limited information available.”

If the worst happens despite your best intentions, D&O insurance can help to protect your assets by covering the legal costs of defending a claim, as well as any damages awarded against you.

Related Articles

Scottish Power logo

Total Gas & Power

Total Gas & Power is a business energy supplier, wholly owned by Total SA. It has been a leading business ...

Read More
SSE logo

SSE

SSE is one of the UK’s leading business energy suppliers, catering for around 500,000 business with electric...

Read More
Scottish Power Logo

Scottish Power

Scottish Power has been operating since 1901 and is now owned by Iberdola, a Spanish energy firm that is one o...

Read More
Excellent, 9.7 / 10

thank you nicole for your kind help to…

"thank you nicole for your kind help to set up my business electric account fantastic service and your personal touch thank you"

This review was posted by Sam Raju on the 19th of February 2018

Aaron Gallagher recently helped me…

"Aaron Gallagher recently helped me switch the gas and electricity supply for our business. He was extremely helpful and well informed which was great for me as I know nothing in this area! He saved us a small fortune and dealt with all of the switch for us which again was extremely helpful as it wasn't completely straightforward. Thanks again for you help Aaron, it was so appreciated."

This review was posted by Rachel on the 17th of February 2018

A better deal for our Village Hall

"I recently used this company to get a better energy deal for our local village hall. Other companies were quite pushy but Lorraine and Bhavni from SwitchMyBusiness were much more professional. They sent me useful information by email enabling me and the village hall committee to make a decision about which supplier to use. The switch was done by phone and when the energy provider sent the paper work to the wrong address Bhavni sorted it out straight away. I saved over £1000 for the charity."

This review was posted by Irene Winter on the 16th of February 2018

Good Service

"Lorraine was great and very helpful. We negotiated and received a good deal on our supply."

This review was posted by Edwina Nash on the 16th of February 2018

The SME Personal Switcher

"The SME Personal Switcher, Lorraine Carey was really helpful."

This review was posted by Cross Fabrications on the 16th of February 2018