Fracking – arguments for and against


What is fracking?

Fracking, also known as hydraulic fracking, uses relatively new methods to access reserves of oil and gas that were once inaccessible or unprofitable. It allows companies to exploit natural gas and oil that are trapped within tightly packed sand and shale. Incredibly high pressurised ‘fracking fluid’, consisting of jets of sand, chemicals and water, is blasted into the ground, breaking open underground reserves. After the pressure is removed, the sand acts as a mechanism to keep the ‘fractures’ open, allowing for extraction.

In what’s being described as a ‘landmark ruling’ for the fracking industry, the Government has approved a fracking application by shale company Cuadrilla

In what’s being described as a ‘landmark ruling’ for the fracking industry, the Government has recently approved a fracking application by shale company Cuadrilla

Sajid Javid, Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, has overturned a ruling by Lancashire County Council against a fracking application by Cuadrilla for a site on the Flyde. This will bring the total number of fracking wells in the UK to five: four wells at the Lancashire site and one in Ryedale, North Yorkshire. Javid has indicated he is inclined to grant permission for a further site, at Roseacre wood. In addition to these sites, there are areas licensed for fracking throughout the UK, including sites near Cardiff and Nottingham.

Fracking is deeply controversial, and it’s an understatement to say that the ruling has been met with a mixed response.

Arguments for fracking

In the prairies of North Dakota, hydraulic fracking is seen by some as a modern incarnation of the American dream. America’s largest fracking site, Bakken Play, once an area of stagnating economic growth, now abounds with newly minted millionaires. Employment rates in the area have skyrocketed. The Fort Berthold Indian Reservation leased their tribal land for drilling and, since 2010, have generated 30 million barrels of oil, and more than $500 million profit. Bakken now produces more oil and gas than it knows what to do with.

What’s more, fracking lowered US energy prices, thanks in part to the shift it allowed from oil to natural gas. Thanks to fracking, the US saw the price of oil drop from $100 per barrel, to $60 a barrel at the start of 2014.

To proponents of the process, fracking opens up a vast new world of of oil and gas reserves. In the UK, there is 1.3 trillion cubic feet of shale gas sitting beneath our feet. If this gas could be exploited, it would have the potential to increase our energy security as well as providing a much needed economic boost. A 2013 report from the Institute of Directors suggested that the introduction of fracking could create 74,000 jobs and generate £3.7 billion per year.

According to Andrea Leadsom, writing in 2015:

“In 2003, we were a net exporter of gas. By 2030 we expect to be importing close to 75% of the gas we consume. By making the most of our home-grown gas we can safeguard our own domestic supply whilst also cutting our carbon emissions.”

Diversification of the energy mix is something that all Governments are mindful of – be that through investigation into new renewables, or the exploitation of existing energy sources.

Cuadrilla CEO Francis Egon, speaking on Good Morning Britain, said:

“The country is running out of gas, and without some form of energy development, we’re going to end up importing all of our fuel from overseas, and we’ve seen that just last week with the ridiculous situation where Scotland is importing shale gas from America, which frankly is crazy.”

Shale gas is slightly more environmentally friendly than coal and oil, meaning that it could be used as a ‘stepping stone’ towards a more sustainable energy mix, weaning us of traditionally generated coal and oil, whilst not compromising energy stability. Reliable, scalable renewable energy sources are difficult to come by, and fracking is often viewed as a practical compromise.

If the US model holds true, fracking also has the potential to usher in an era of cheap gas, reducing domestic energy bills.

Arguments against fracking

Fracking is exploratory within the UK. That means that, of that 1.3 trillion cubic feet of gas below us, we don’t actually know how much will be extractable. If the amount falls to the lower end of the scale, we may see no change to energy bills, little job creation and no economic benefit. Any disruption to the British countryside, any Government investment, will have been for nothing. What’s more, fracking’s effect on gas bills is far from a sure thing: the UK’s gas network is different to America’s.  In 2013, Cuadrilla’s chairman said:

“We are part of a well-connected European gas market and, unless it is a gigantic amount of gas, it is not going to have material impact on price,”

Economic impact aside, most arguments against fracking relate to its potential environmental effects. Reports have highlighted the potential for up to 100,000 wells in the UK, each at a size of around 7,000 sqm. Communities in at-risk areas have voiced worries about water, air, noise and traffic pollution, as well as the unpleasant effects of industrialising the countryside. In America, there is evidence that fracking has led to polluted water supplies and rural air pollution akin to a smog filled city.  

Shale gas may be seen as a lesser evil in energy generation, however it is debated how low carbon fracking is compared to coal. Anti-fracking proponents have pointed to the paradox of investing in carbon intensive production whilst also supporting the Paris Agreement – a deal between 55 countries which requires Governments to produce and report upon plans to reduce carbon emissions. Environmentalists worry that fracking may divert funds away from renewables, which could be detrimental in the long term, especially if investigation into potentially profitable renewable energy sources is neglected.

Finally, fracking has a controversial link to earthquakes. We know that the high-intensity injection of fracking fluid increases pressure on seismic faults, making them more likely to slip. We also know that earthquakes far afield can trigger smaller tremors at fracking wells. Cuadrilla’s Lancashire site has already registered a couple of minor quakes. There are worries that fracking may affect the world’s vulnerability to earthquakes in ways we don’t yet comprehend.

How do you feel about the recent Government announcement? Share your thoughts with us on Twitter.

 

Related Articles

Powerlines-into-sunrise

Energy News – 27/06/2017

A deal with the DUP may be yet to materialise, but that hasn’t stopped the Queen’s speech going ahead, wit...

Read More

Switching just got simpler for micro businesses

45% of micro businesses are stuck on expensive deals New regulations from the CMA will make it easier for thes...

Read More
Business-electricity-coal-power-to-end-by-2023-big-coal-stockpile-at-sunrise

Energy News 16/06/2017

Michael Gove is appointed energy secretary, suppliers continue to fall short on digital offerings and global e...

Read More
Excellent, 9.7 / 10

Extremely helpful and clear to understand

"I have found the information and assistance to be very clear, and helpful. I was helped through the process of switching electricity supply by personal switching assistant Suhan Ashan who was not only helpful, but very patient in explaining all of the queries which I had and also researching the estimated KwH for our newly acquired office premises, as we had no previous tenant information."

This review was posted by Sue Williams on the 24th of July 2017

Jessica help us arrange new deals for …

"Jessica help us arrange new deals for our start up business which was greatly useful particularly in time during busy setting out period"

This review was posted by Allan on the 21st of July 2017

Really good doing business with Mark …

"Really good doing business with Mark Weeks and SwitchMyBusiness. Getting good energy deals for not-for-profit organisations are a nightmare but Mark made it really easy for us. Very many thanks, well done!"

This review was posted by Tony Smith on the 20th of July 2017

Spoke with Mark Weeks great guy always …

"Spoke with Mark Weeks great guy always phoned back or email when he said he would and was a great help. Would use him again any time."

This review was posted by Duncan Winton on the 20th of July 2017

Courteous and knowledgeable.

"I had my business transfer handled by Mark Weeks, he was courteous and knowledgeable about the various different tariffs on offer and made the process quick and simple. I would definitely recommend their services."

This review was posted by Lawrie Sharp on the 19th of July 2017