How much could your business save?Find out now!
Or, you can call us on:0800 411 8830

Business insurance rated worst for customer experience

Insurance offers the worst customer experience, according to new insurance research. Why are UK SMEs getting such a poor deal and what can be done?

Service design consultancy Engine’s latest annual Customer Experience Survey compared 14 major industry sectors. Just 11% of respondents rated the insurance customer experience, followed by automotive and utilities (both 12%). The retail sector has the best customer experience (38%).

Insurance suffers two key problems in terms of customer experience, says Oliver King, co-founder of Engine. “It’s a product people are obliged to have rather than want. Plus, on the rare occasions they do interact with the provider, it normally has negative connotations.”

But some insurers may retort that customers in their industry are less influenced by quality of service and customer experience. In fact, the survey data does bear this out to some degree: insurance ranks eleventh (16%) of consumers’ choice of provider being influenced by experience, against fourth (26%) for banking and first for food services/ restaurants (cited by 35%).

Progressive insurance

Such a stance is short sighted: the same research shows that openness/honesty is the most valued trait in the provision of customer service and experience (49% of respondents), followed by efficiency (43%) and reliability (41%). All three of the most valued traits become a bigger factor with age – particularly openness/honesty.

“Insurers can’t afford to think about what’s important to their ‘average customer’ – that person doesn’t exist,” notes King.

This is even more evident in the SMEs, he adds, as smaller businesses in many sectors, not just insurance, are often under-served because service providers have tended to divide their efforts squarely between corporates and consumers.

“The SME economy continues to grow and the hybrid needs of SMEs now represent a great opportunity for insurers. SMEs need the product modularity and the absolute certainty expected by corporates, as well as the simplicity and immediacy expected by consumers. Unlike consumers and corporates, SMEs need insurers to recognise the pace and fragility of smaller businesses and see flexibility, understanding and direct access to a person who can help, as vital. Most importantly, SMEs don’t have the admin resources of larger businesses – owner-managed businesses feel this most acutely. Both self-serve business products and high-touch personal service are appealing.”

Compare market insurance

Not all SMEs share the same values when it comes to buying business products and services, King says. “Our research on SMEs buying a range of business products and employee benefits has revealed three broad attitudinal segments: those that will always buy in price, those that are looking for a partner that can support them in delivering their business objectives, and those that will pay more for great service because they see the value in removing the burden of administration from their business – they’ll pay never to have to worry again.”

Find out more about Engine at


Related Articles

the week's top energy news

The Week’s Top Energy News

Top News In Energy This Week This week we’ve seen a flurry of green energy stories – including gr...

Read More

Very Clever Commuting Hacks

It’s easy to focus on the downsides of a long commute. The average UK commuter spends 58 minutes every ...

Read More
will innovative jam boost the economy

Will ‘innovative jam’ boost the UK economy?

It’s the economic equivalent of Union Jack bunting. Today, in a move surely masterminded by the Great Briti...

Read More
Excellent, 9.4 / 10

Competent and courteous service.

"Marie was knowledgeable and helpful. I feel able to recommend the service given without reservation. David Slesenger"

This review was posted by David Slesenger on the 16th of August 2016

Good service

"Nadia was very helpful"

This review was posted by Robin on the 16th of August 2016

Excellent Customer Service *****

"Jonathan Burgess is an asset to Switch My Business. He made me feel at ease and was more than helpful at all times. He made regular contact and guided me through the whole process which made switching a breeze. I just wish there were more customer service advisers like Jonathon whose friendly and happy demeanour make your day a much nicer one. Well done Switch my business and more importantly thank you Jonathon for all your hard work! Maria Owen Lodgecrest"

This review was posted by Maria Owen on the 17th of August 2016


"I totally agree with a customer maria owen,Jonathan Burgess was such a pleasure dealing with and is truly a asset to the company, he made it very easy to switch my electricity companies, Jonathan Burgess was very helpful, easy to talk to it was like talking to a friend not just a customer adviser. I would definitely recommend switchmybusiness and try get hold off Jonathan Burgess if possible and have the same excellent service as I did. Rajan Shanan"

This review was posted by Rajan Shanan on the 19th of August 2016

Excellent and very helpful

"Arron who dealt with my switch of energy and gas has been a huge help and extremely efficienct and easy to deal with. Despite British Gas throwing obstacles in the way at every turn he has doggedly stuck to his task and saved the day. Thanks Arron."

This review was posted by Rod Pryce-Jones on the 19th of August 2016